Sunday, October 17, 2010

Choosing Your Audio Software

I've been getting a lot of questions about what software I recommend for audio manipulation, so I've decided to write up a guide to choosing your software, or DAW (Digital Audio Workstation) as it is called.
The problem with choosing a DAW is that there are only a few things you want your DAW to be able to do. You want to be able to record things. You want to be able to comfortably manipulate audio samples. You want to apply effects to audio tracks. You want to export your work. That's it. In essence, every DAW needs to do this, and every single one does. They differ in workflow, in lay-out, looks and only marginally in features.
Now that we have established this, I'll run down the main options you have here.

1. Logic Studio/Express (Mac)
Once a cross-platform DAW, Apple bought Logic and made it Mac-exclusive. Logic has a reputation of being a all-in-one package, that does everything in a very intuitive way. Express is a stripped-down version of Studio that is still very rich in features. Most studios use Macs, and most of those Macs run Logic. It used to be really expensive, but with the latest update, Apple made the wise choice of making it affordable, with some amazing value for your money.

2. Steinberg Cubase (PC/Mac)
This is the DAW that introduced VST plug-ins, which caused a major turnabout in the DAW world. Many producers switched to this DAW because of it, and it has a reputation for great cross-platform support. The downside is that it has a notoriously difficult interface.

3. Cakewalk Sonar (PC)
The fact that Sonar only runs on PC has made it a very strange little piece of software. In a market dominated by Macs, choosing only to release on PC comes with a very unprofessional image. I have never worked with Sonar, but it's not very expensive, and there's still a good number of people who swear by it.

4. DigiDesign Pro Tools (PC/Mac)
The cross-platform powerhouse. Comes with a PCI card for its DSP technology and output. I've never used it, because it's really really expensive, and is most popular among professional producers.

5. Cockos Reaper (PC/Mac)
I already had a discussion on Reaper here. Basically, it costs next to nothing and works like a charm. Very safe choice for anyone entering the world of digital audio.

6. Ableton Live (PC/Mac)
My favourite, by far. Live does not focus on offering a complete package, it focuses on making making music fun. Comes with a good set of tutorials that will have you feeling like a DJ in no-time. Live is based on looping samples, which makes it extremely accessible and allows you to easily experiment with different ideas. There was a time when Ableton was considered unworthy because of its poor sound engine and choice of fun over power, but the latest versions have addressed those problems.

7. FL Studio (PC)
Another strange little DAW that does everything in a slightly different way. Like Live, it focuses on fun rather than features, but like Sonar, is considered slightly unprofessional. Not only is it PC-exclusive, it also does not allow the use of VST plugins. Still, there are plenty of productions made by this program. One of the top DnB producers in the world, Spor, uses this for most of his tunes, which I think is all the evidence you need.

8. Propellerhead Reason/Rekord (PC/Mac)
A very hands-on approach. Probably the most intuitive DAW of the lot. Not very feature rich, but still offers a few things that other DAWs don't, especially in terms of interface. It's clearly oriented towards electronic music production, and therefore lacks some features that I find essential, but I still have it on my computer. Why? It is very easy to integrate with other programmes. I can use Reason's output in Ableton, which combines their functionality.

31 comments:

  1. I've mucked around with FL Studio, not tried the others

    ReplyDelete
  2. great list, I have dabbled with Reason a few times, and it is alright.

    ReplyDelete
  3. thank you very much for this post.. I've been using adobe audition, formerly known as cool edit for a while now, and it is good enough for me.. I can record instruments, vocals, everything and it supports vst plugins... which is very cool.. also I use it on my laptop with asio4all drivers and stock audio card built in... Its amateur, but it works pretty good :D

    I'm downloading ableton live, wanna give that a try :)

    saving this post to favs :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. im running cubase and ableton currently with ableton to be my favorite by far. cubase is kinda difficult lol

    ReplyDelete
  5. What would you recommend under Linux? (Other than the above +WINE.)

    ReplyDelete
  6. A really good friend of mine is a 25+ year professional audio engineer vet, and he said it's Digidesign or nothing. Plus apparently the Mac platform for Pro Tools has been broken wide open, or so he says.

    ReplyDelete
  7. man i've used sound recorder for ages, such good sound quality on that program!!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. TIme to invest! I need a good DAW. Garage Band is not cuttin' it. And n-track Studio for Mac is balls. Are these ranked in order of preference, or is it just a random listing?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Never even heard of steinberg, but I have used cakewalk before. I'll have to check that out.

    ReplyDelete
  10. fruity loops is pretty cool, i used to have it...

    ReplyDelete
  11. great guide , i was using FL myself. I was thinking of changing.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Finally switched over to Reaper after using Audacity for years. Very daunting to start using these more professional DAWs (considering Audacity is more or less a glorified "Record" button) but I'm starting to see what separates the low-end stuff from the "big hitters".

    ReplyDelete
  13. Abelton is the way to go. It takes awhile to master completely, but once you do, the possibilities are endless. Literally. Good overview man. You rule :D

    ReplyDelete
  14. FL studio is a nice introductory program.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Yeah, I like FL Studio. I'm just like that.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Pro Tools, FL Studio & Logic are my main DaWs, depending on what I'm doing.

    Look out for upcoming exclusive mixing series tutorials on my blog!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Useful blog, keep the level this high!

    ReplyDelete
  19. personally, i use steinberg. someone teached me some stuff with it, and it's all i need so i'm gonna stick with it.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks for the tips. Really useful blog :)

    +1 follow

    ReplyDelete
  21. I use both Ableton and Sonar for production and I still use Sound Forge for manipulation.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I use reaper and it works very well

    ReplyDelete
  23. Digidesign is solid, too, I think

    ReplyDelete
  24. i use audiocity for all my audio stuff. :O

    ReplyDelete